A Tragic Weekend at the Waldorf: A Fort William Misfortune

A Tragic Weekend at the Waldorf: A Fort William Misfortune | Alex Inspired

Not up for reading right now? Maybe you’d prefer to listen to this story below. 

Eugene Grimes Murphy, Fort William - Alex Inspired

Eugene Grimes Murphy was the son of Annie and James Murphy (the famous coal merchant and owner of the Fort William Times Journal) The Murphy’s were an elite Fort William family with James serving as mayor twice, living in the coveted Murphy Mansion located on Selkirk Street.

Grimes Murphy, from my research, was an exceptional young man with a good disposition and a kind heart. He attended Fort William Collegiate and was highly involved in the local hockey scene. After High School he continued his education at Loyola College, earning a Bachelor of Arts Degree. He attended Osgoode Hall Law School – only to be interrupted by the First World War. Grimes entered the Canadian Aviation Forces serving overseas for a short period of time. On his return to Canada, he was called to the bar on October 16th, 1919.

Meeting of Convocation text - Eugene Grimes Murphy | Alex Inspired

Interesting Tidbit:

His name, was a tribute to his mother’s maiden name, Grimes. Not to be confused with Frank Grimes, from the Simpsons.

After opening his firm, Grimes ran for Fort William City Council – you can read more about it here, via the City of Thunder Bay Website.

Grimes ran for Mayor and won, serving from 1931 – 1932. He was the first Mayor to have been born in Fort William and the only Fort William Mayor born to a previous Mayor. After his father’s death, he along with his brothers continued on with the family businesses, giving up his law practice permanently.

A Tragic End

In 1933, Grimes along with his mother and brother James, travelled to New York City on business, and stayed in a 10th floor suite at the Waldorf-Astoria.

The Waldorf-Astoria Vintage Postcard

In attempting to open the window, Grimes suddenly lunged forward and went through the glass. He fell 5 stories and landed on a mesh barrier above the 5th floor skylight, dying instantly.

The incident left everyone shaken and rumours of suicide surrounded the Murphy family.

Newspaper Article from New York City - E.G. Murphy | Alex Inspired

An autopsy was performed by Dr. Norris, the New York Medical Examiner, delaying travel for the Murphy family to return home with the body of Grimes. During the inquest, James Murphy told police he believed his brother had a heart attack. It was later discovered Grimes had suffered from a bout of pneumonia the year before, causing irreparable damage to his heart and he was in New York to see a heart specialist.

Witnesses and guests from across the way gave witness to Grimes collapsing against the draft pane, breaking through the glass and plunging towards the skylight. The autopsy later confirmed his death as an accident.

Time Chronicle Port Arthur Ontario - Death of E. Grimes Murphy | Alex Inspired

Upon return to Fort William, his funeral was one of the largest of its time, with a funeral procession from his family home to St. Patrick church and finally to his resting place in St. Patrick’s Cemetery.  Countless community members from the Twin cities attended, including: the Canadian Legion, Fort William Rotary Club, The Thunder Bay Bar Association Members, City Council members, Board of Education members, Knights of Columbus and Polish and Italian Societies. His honourary pallbearers were all former Fort Willam Mayors – Hogarth, Dyke, Jackson, Rutledge, Edmeston, Crawford and Darrell.

Eugene Grimes Murphy accomplished so much in his short time on earth. His achievements and community involvement have left a trail for people like me, to find through newspapers and books. These tidbits of information are only the tip of the iceberg – he wholeheartedly left a legacy Fort William and Port Arthur citizens can be proud of. For he and his family are an lasting thread of our past.

If you liked this post, you might like others! Subscribe below by email and have stories straight to your inbox!

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Leave a comment, below.

You Might Also Like


  • Reply Karen Skochinski March 31, 2019 at 8:55 am

    Hi Alex

    I didn’t know your blog existed until it popped up on Thunder Bay Memories. Great work! What an interesting bit of history. I remember you dancing at many Robbie Burns Nights. Did you take history at LU?

    My name is Karen Skochinski and your father sometime drove me(flute) and an oboeist to TBSO rehearsals back in the 70s. Such a nice guy and what a terrible loss for your family. Your Mom was a super WW leader. I can still picture her and hear her voice. Thunder Bay is a small town in many ways.

    I hope you and your family are doing well.

  • Reply Mila September 5, 2021 at 1:54 am

    Was there any interesting deaths that took place in the murphy family?

  • Reply Submitted for the approval of the Midnight Society - Alex Inspired April 3, 2023 at 5:01 pm

    […] A Tragic Weekend at the Waldorf – A Fort William Misfortune This year you can LISTEN to the story about Fort William’s own, Eugene Grimes Murphy. Yes, you can listen above *just click or tap the graphic* to hear this story and learn more about the family who constructed the beautiful Murphy Mansion on Selkirk. […]

  • Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.